DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! rise up Rochester is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

  • Subscribe

  • Community

  • Top Commenters

  • Popular Threads

  • Recent Comments

    • Hey Sean, this is a great film for opening people's minds. I'm not sure how I feel about all of his claims. I've watched the film twice now, the first time was over the summer and the...

      3 months ago by Andrew S.

      in Esoteric Agenda film by Ben Stewart

    • Hey I was there last Thursday, the day after the measure was defeated. The good news is that this radical legislation got about 40% support, which means it could likely pass next year. Also, the...

      3 months ago by Andrew S.

      in Restoring the Republic?

    • This sounds a lot like the artist guilds of antiquity, which, while providing an organization to the community was also considered oppressive and constricting, effectively censoring countless...

      3 months ago by Sandwich

      in Government and the Arts

    • Anybody who couldn't spot this charlatan from the back in the summer really should precluded themselves from voting until they develop better recognition skills. How many times did I hear this...

      4 months ago by LogicalUS

      in Obama Poster: New Face, Same Tyranny

    • Great poster - I used it on my site for my latest column. http://www.cbrookskurtz.com/articles/2009/3/5/you-have-nothing-to-fear-but-your-hopes-and-dreams.html?SSScrollPosition=0

      4 months ago by CBK

      in Obama Poster: New Face, Same Tyranny

rise up Rochester

energizing the peaceful resistance in Western New York
Jump to original thread »
Author

Fourth Plane Shot Down on 9/11

Started by Andrew S. · 8 months ago

I remember a couple of years back telling my friends who were on their way to see United 93 that it was pure propaganda and not believe a word of it. They replied in disbelief and questioned my assertion, but I quickly replied that the movie was released just five years after the events of 9/11 ... Continue reading »

12 comments

  • Thank you for tracking this story, and posting the info about the Guantanamo testimony.

    Far more than the Rumsfeld "slip of the lip", the testimony -- especially given the tone of the question from the US military attorney -- vindicates everything that I've written and said on the radio for years.

    Flight 93 WAS shot down.
    http://www.renewamerica.us/columns/kovach/050914


    Tom Kovach
  • I have actually never heard that theory before. That is interesting though...
  • Comment removed.
  • In case you didn't know:

    propaganda |ˌpräpəˈgandə|
    noun
    1 chiefly derogatory information, esp. of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote or publicize a particular political cause or point of view : he was charged with distributing enemy propaganda.
    • the dissemination of such information as a political strategy : the party's leaders believed that a long period of education and propaganda would be necessary .
    2 ( Propaganda) a committee of cardinals of the Roman Catholic Church responsible for foreign missions, founded in 1622 by Pope Gregory XV.
    ORIGIN Italian, from modern Latin congregatio de propaganda fide ‘congregation for propagation of the faith’ ( see sense 2). Sense 1 dates from the early 20th cent.

    In other words, it doesn't have to be put out by the government to be propaganda. Anyone making a film about a political event is entering into the conversation about that event and PROPOGATING a view about it. The dictionary happens to use examples that talk about large institutions like the Church and a political party, but as I said, others can put out propaganda too.

    Clearly those who made this film knew that it would demonize Muslims and rally support for the War on Terror by using the emotions surrounding the United 93 incident.
  • My words exactly Alicia
  • Comment removed.
  • I'm not even going to address most of this, but I will say that you are calling me childish because you don't like the real definition of propaganda.
  • Also, you'll notice that I haven't commented on many of your claims stating things that I supposedly agree with. I don't really feel it necessary to tell you my specific and actual beliefs as I know that you will just project what you think I believe onto this site. The joke is really on you in the end, because you don't know who I am or what I believe. You've just taken two comments and the fact that I am here to create your own vision. I'd advise you not to do so.
  • Also, I've mentioned this before, but if you don't stop with the harassing comments about mental illness and murder I will personally make sure that you're comments do not appear on this site. It is purely uncalled for, but I realize that when people are uncomfortable with views different from their own they often have to resort to this tactic. As I mentioned before, I really don't want to engage in any conversation with you, because I think it just fuels your mission. Seriously though, I believe in free speech, but your comments are troubling and flat out creepy. I'm not interested in discussing 9/11 truth with you either. So, either politely state your differences and refute issues at hand, or be banned.
  • So let me get this straight:

    United 93 - privately financed, produced by professionals and sold for a profit = not propaganda
    Alternative media films - privately financed, produced by professionals and sold for a profit (as well as put on the internet for free) = people that are just out to get your money

    Oh, ok....
  • No, no, don't do that false dichotomy thing again, Andrew. I don't believe that all producers of alternative media films are out to get your money. I will say that Alex Jones is just out to get your money ... in fact, he seems to beg for it constantly on his radio show.
  • Good for him. I'm sure not going to work for free my whole life. If people are willing to send him donations or buy his products, more power to him. Don't hate the player, hate the game.

Add New Comment

Returning? Login